What Is The Difference Between Tremors And Parkinson’s Disease
While the majority of Parkinson’s patients experience tremors,not everyone who has tremors has Parkinson’s. Tremors are also asymptom of other conditions, such as traumatic brain injury, stroke, certainmedicines, alcohol poisoning or anxiety.
Tremor is an unintentional, rhythmic musclecontraction that leads to shaking in one or more parts of thebody. Parkinson’s disease is a neurological disorder that causes tremors,stiffness in limbs and loss of coordination.
The most significant difference between tremor associated withParkinson’s disease and tremor associated with other conditions is thatParkinson’s tremor is typically a “resting tremor,” meaning it ispresent when an individual is at rest and goes away when the individual isactive. Tremors in most other conditions are classified as “actiontremor,” meaning shaking increases when a person is active and decreaseswhen the person is at rest.
While Parkinson’s is typically the most widely-known disease associatedwith tremor, a condition called essential tremor is more common, affectingapproximately 5% of people aged 65 and older.
Clinical Situation #3: Et Or Et+pd
A 40-year-old woman with a family history of ET develops a kinetic tremor and, a few years later, a postural head tremor. Her tremor worsens considerably such that she has severe and debilitating tremor by the age of 65 years. At 70 years of age, she also develops a tremor at rest with no other features of parkinsonism.
This patient likely only has ET with isolated rest tremor, a feature that can develop in ET cases with longstanding and severe disease.
Essential Tremor Vs Parkinson’s Tremors: A Guide To The Major Differences
When people think of Parkinson’sdisease, they may picture the shaking hands commonly associated with thecondition. Persistent shaking of hands and limbsalso known as tremorcan makeit difficult to write a grocery list, hold a cup of tea, button a shirt andapply makeup, among other routine tasks. When tremors interfere with dailylife, it can be very disruptive. While tremors are a hallmark of Parkinson’spatients, there are other diseases similar to Parkinson’s that can causetremors.
Is Head Tremor The Same As Essential Tremor
Head tremor is often described as an oscillation of the head, causing it to move side to side or up and down. The tremor can be rhythmic like a pendulum or irregular and more pronounced. While head tremors can be one of many types of tremors experienced by those with essential tremor, they are also seen in patients with dystonia.;
How Can You Tell The Difference Between Essential Tremor And Parkinsons Disease
Essential tremor is a neurological disorder that causes tremors, generally of both hands, but also the head and voice. It is often confused with Parkinsons disease, but the tremor in essential tremor is an action tremor, which means that the tremor is most noticeable when the limb is in use or moving and improves when the limb is at rest. This is opposite of the tremor seen in Parkinsons disease, which is most noticeable when the limbs are relaxed and at rest, and lessens when the affected limb is in use.
You May Like: Parkinson Disease Life Span
S Of The Body Affected
The tremor in PD usually starts on one side of the body and may develop on the other side as the disease progresses. In ET, the tremor usually affects both sides from the beginning of the condition.2
The hands are more often affected with tremor than the legs in people with PD, and the voice and head are almost never involved. In ET, the hands are also predominantly affected, but the tremor can also be present in the head and voice.2,3
What Is The Difference Between Essential Tremor Vs Parkinsons Disease
Essential tremor vs. Parkinsons disease have several noticeable differences. Essential tremor symptoms are more pronounced during activity, whereas Parkinsons tremors tend to occur more regularly at rest. Essential tremor is typically only associated with tremors, while Parkinsons disease generally includes tremors along with rigidity, problems walking, and issues with balance.
The amplitude and frequency of tremors also differ between essential tremor and Parkinsons disease. Essential tremor symptoms tend to be of a lower amplitude with a higher frequency, and Parkinsons disease tremors are more often higher amplitude with lower frequency.
Essential tremor is most often tied to a family history, and Parkinsons disease is rarely tied to family history. Essential tremor is roughly 10 times more common in the U.S. than Parkinsons disease.
Another interesting difference is that alcohol may improve tremors for essential tremor patients but tends to have no effect on tremors of Parkinsons patients.
A by the International Essential Tremor Foundation.
Parkinsons Vs Essential Tremor: The Timing Of The Tremor
Parkinsons patients most commonly experience tremors when theyre at rest, meaning theyre not currently doing anything else with the part of the body in question. The tremor will come to an end when you start doing something else with your hand, leg, or wherever else the tremor is like simply moving it.;
People with Essential Tremor, meanwhile, primarily experience tremors when they are active and moving these are called action tremors. Somewhere between 20 and 30 percent of people with Essential Tremor also do experience rest tremors, however, so having those doesnt necessarily mean you have Parkinsons. Where ET patients do have rest tremors, theyre more likely to strike the arm. This;isnt true for people living with Parkinsons disease, who can have rest tremors in varied body parts.
How Are Tremors And Dyskinesia Experienced By Caregivers
People with Parkinsons disease can experience their condition much differently than do their caregivers or spouses. Sometimes being in the off state looks more comfortable to the caregiver because the person is still, and can even seem kind of calm, says Herrington. But for the person with Parkinsons, they experience that off state as very uncomfortable. They may describe it as feeling trapped because they want to move but and they cant.
In this case, he continues, the person might say, Look, I know I have dyskinesia, but I prefer being free to move than feeling stuck and trapped. The caregiver, however, may feel bothered by the increased movement, he says, and think that the person is taking too much medication.
There can be a real disconnect there between what the patient would want and what the caregiver might think is best, says Herrington. Its not always the best thing to try to get rid of every last bit of dyskinesia, because the person might be less comfortable in that state.
You May Like: Why Do Parkinson’s Patients Hallucinate
What Side Of The Body Is Affected By Tremors
Parkinson’s-related tremor is well-known to typically initially;manifest itself on only one side of the body. It will often go on to affect both sides only later on, as the disease enters its later stages, but one side of the body will still remain disproportionally prone to tremor.;People with Essential Tremor, on the other hand, tend to have “symmetrical” or “bilateral” tremors from the very start.;
What Is The Difference Between Tremors And Parkinsons Disease
While the majority of Parkinsons patients experience tremors,not everyone who has tremors has Parkinsons. Tremors are also asymptom of other conditions, such as traumatic brain injury, stroke, certainmedicines, alcohol poisoning or anxiety.
Tremor is an unintentional, rhythmic musclecontraction that leads to shaking in one or more parts of thebody. Parkinsons disease is a neurological disorder that causes tremors,stiffness in limbs and loss of coordination.
The most significant difference between tremor associated withParkinsons disease and tremor associated with other conditions is thatParkinsons tremor is typically a resting tremor, meaning it ispresent when an individual is at rest and goes away when the individual isactive. Tremors in most other conditions are classified as actiontremor, meaning shaking increases when a person is active and decreaseswhen the person is at rest.
While Parkinsons is typically the most widely-known disease associatedwith tremor, a condition called essential tremor is more common, affectingapproximately 5% of people aged 65 and older.
Read Also: Can Someone With Parkinson’s Drive
Characteristics Of An Essential Tremor
- An essential tremor is an action tremor, where there is a combination of postural and kinetic tremor in various degrees. The patient may have problems such as difficulty in holding a glass without spilling, shaving, or eating but there is no tremor on rest.
- Genetic factors play an important role in essential tremor and is inherited as an autosomal dominant gene.
- Essential tremor is bilateral and the hands are almost always affected, along with the face, head or trunk. Lower extremities are rarely affected.
- Absence of neurological signs.
- Isolated head tremor without problems in posture.
- Absence of features of Parkinsons disease associated with bradykinesia and rigidity.
- Cause of essential tremor is not known.
- Medicines responds well to primidone and beta-adrenergic blockers such as propranolol but does not respond to anti-Parkinson medications.
Diagnostic Criteria For Et & Pd
Two sets of criteria are commonly used for the diagnosis of ET. For definite ET, the diagnostic criteria proposed by the Movement Disorder Society require the presence of persistent, bilateral postural tremor of the forearms . Kinetic tremor may be present, but is not necessary for the diagnosis . No other abnormal neurological signs may be present, except for Froments sign, which is a cogwheel phenomenon without rigidity . For definite ET, the criteria proposed by the Washington Heights-Inwood Genetic Study of Essential Tremor require the presence of moderate amplitude postural tremor as well as kinetic tremor, with the latter resulting in impairment of activities of daily living .
The UK Parkinsons Disease Society Brain Bank criteria require postmortem confirmation for the diagnosis of definite PD . The diagnosis of probable PD requires bradykinesia and one of the following additional features: rigidity, 46-Hz rest tremor or postural instability . In addition, three supportive features are required . The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke criteria for PD only include clinical criteria for possible PD, which require three out of four of the following features: rest tremor, bradykinesia, rigidity or asymmetric onset .
Also Check: What’s The Difference Between Ms And Parkinson’s
Medications For Essential Tremor
Propanolol and primidone are two of the medicines often prescribed to treat essential tremor.
Propanolol blocks the stimulating action of neurotransmitters to calm your trembling. This beta blocker is effective in 40% to 50% of patients and is less useful in reducing head and voice tremor. It is usually avoided in patients with asthma, emphysema, congestive heart failure or heart block, and should be used with caution by people with diabetes who are on insulin. These drugs may reduce exercise tolerance, lower blood pressure or heart rate, exacerbate depression and cause impotence. Other adrenergic blockers with fewer side effects include atenolol, nadolol, metoprolol and timolol.
Primidone controls the actions of neurotransmitters. Some patients starting primidone may experience a first dose phenomenon during which they have transient feelings of unsteadiness, dizziness and nausea during the beginning stages of treatment. This is usually short-lived. Sedation is another common side effect and can be reduced by following a slowly escalating dose schedule. Most patients are able to tolerate the side effects, and studies have shown that 60% to 100% of patients respond positively.
If primidone or propranolol are not effective by themselves, a combination of both may provide relief for some patients.
Parkinson’s Disease Vs Essential Tremor: The Diagnostic Process
- Patient reports on their symptoms
- Diagnostic checklists;
- Physical examinations of various kinds, such as being asked to complete certain activities
- A look at your family history
Your doctor may also:
- Order a;dopamine transporter imaging test Parkinson’s disease patients gradually lose dopamine, so test results indicative of this suggest Parkinson’s disease.
- Use techniques such as;accelerometry;to look at the severity and patterns of your tremors.;
- Test your sense of smell, something that is often affected in people with Parkinson’s disease.
- Fekete R, Jankovic J. Revisiting the relationship between essential tremor and Parkinsons disease. Mov Disord 2011,26:391-398.
Recommended Reading: How To Treat Parkinson’s Naturally
Misperception #6: Bradykinesia = Pd
Bradykinesia is a cardinal sign of PD. Although bradykinesia is not traditionally associated with ET, there have been several studies that report the contrary. One study quantified rapid alternating pronation-supination movements in 10 ET cases, 20 mild to moderate PD cases and 10 controls . Post hoc analysis demonstrated that rapid alternating movement cycle duration was statistically longer in ET cases compared with controls, and similar to PD cases . Another study, involving 61 ET cases and 122 controls, evaluated performance in four timed tests involving hand movements, as well as walking and visual reaction time . ET cases compared with controls had longer mean finger tapping times and mean visual reaction times . Another study reported reduced arm swing in 18/136 clinically diagnosed ET cases . While a small proportion of ET cases may exhibit slower movement times than controls, a reduction in amplitude and cessation of movement during rapid successive movements has not been demonstrated in ET.
Clinical pearl #6: Slower movement times may be observed in some patients with ET, yet other features of bradykinesia have not been demonstrated in ET.
Parkinson’s Disease Vs Essential Tremor Early Symptoms How They Differ
As many as one million Americans currently live with Parkinson’s disease and approximately 60,000 Americans are diagnosed each year. Around the world, more than 10 million people worldwide are living with the disease, according to the Parkinsons Disease Foundation.
A new study published in the journal; Brain;has shed new light on the genetics behind essential tremor, which is frequently misdiagnosed as Parkinson’s disease. Understanding the differences between both diseases is key to reducing the prevalence of medical mistakes. Heres everything you need to know about both diseases.
Researchers are examining the genetics behind how essential tremor affects the body.Photo courtesy of Simon Gerard
You May Like: What Happens In Late Stages Of Parkinson’s Disease
What Is Parkinsons Disease
Parkinsons disease is a progressive condition that causes trouble with movement. Its caused by the death of cells in a part of the brain called the substantia nigra. This part of your brain produces the neurotransmitter dopamine.
In some cases, specific genetic mutations are linked to the development of Parkinsons. But more often, it seems to appear randomly. Its thought that environmental factors such as exposure to pesticides, herbicides, or air pollution may contribute, but more evidence is needed to understand the potential link.
According to the National Institute on Aging, Parkinsons most commonly develops in people over the age of 60 and affects men about 50 percent more often than women.
How Tremors Impact Function And What You Can Do About It
When we are toddlers we are constantly problem-solving how to accomplish a task and creating neural pathways that become stronger with each repetition. As adults our brains are wired to accomplish the task without thinking about it. We put our jacket on in the same way everyday. When you experience tremors, suddenly the way youve always done something doesnt work. Its incredibly frustrating! But there are so many ways to accomplish a task; and learning to modify your movements, your environment, or the activity itself can provide great satisfaction and improved quality of life.
Begin to build the habit of asking yourself some questions:
What can I change about the actual task?What can I change about the environment?What can I change in myself to accomplish the task?
People who experience resting tremors might have difficulty with activities that require fine motor skills, such as handwriting, buttoning buttons, zipping zippers, handling money, etc.
Is there a pen that you can use to help write? Try something thicker, heavier, or a different ink. Does it help to support your arm on a surface or closer to your body? Does it help to sit or stand? Can you use voice recognition software? What accessibility options are available on my smartphone or computer?
Can you wear clothes that dont have fasteners? Can you pull the fabric over a button instead of pinching the button? Can you use a key ring on a zipper to help pull it up?
Recommended Reading: Are Parkinson’s Tremors Worse In The Morning
What Is The Difference Between Essential Tremor Andparkinson’s
The exact cause of essential tremor is unknown while Parkinson’sdisease is better understood.
In Parkinson’s disease, neurons located in the part of the brain thatcontrols movement become impaired or die. These neurons usually produce achemical called dopamine which enables regular body movements. When the neuronscan’t produce necessary levels of dopamine, tremors can occur, along withrigidity of limbs and decreased coordination.
Diseases That Mimic Essential Tremor
To be diagnosed with essential tremor, one must first exclude known mimics. More serious problems such as multiple sclerosis, traumatic brain injury, tumors, vascular disease, Wilson’s disease, atypical Parkinson’s disease, drugs, toxins, and more can cause a tremor that worsens when the hand and arm are in use. If one of these things is found to be the cause of the tremor, the tremor is not considered “essential,” but part of a more serious medical condition.
The controversy begins after we have excluded as many of those disorders as possible, and only the tremor seems to remain. Even then, there may be hints that the tremor is a sign of a wider, more involved process in the body.
What Is Parkinsonian Tremor
Like dyskinesia, a parkinsonian tremor involves involuntary muscle movements. Unlike dyskinesia, however, a tremor is characterized by regular, rhythmic movements.
A tremor can affect one or more parts of the body, with the most common being a persons hands. In the early stages of Parkinsons, tremor is typically seen on one side of the body often starting in a hand; however, as Parkinsons progresses, tremor may impact both sides and affect more body regions.
Typically, Parkinsons tremors, often referred to as a rest tremor, occur when the person is at rest or under emotional or physical stress. During sleep and other relaxed states, and when the affected part of the body is actively moving, tremors often subside.
Regardless of the body parts they affect, tremors can interfere with routine activities such as writing, shaving, getting dressed, tying shoelaces, cutting, and other tasks that require fine motor coordination.